Siobhan Magnus American Idol reinstatement petition grows

siobhan magnus shouldve won! she should be in american idol still!

I have been bouncing around the internet reading peoples reactions to Siobhan being eliminated.Most of the posters like Siobhan very much but there is one female poster who is spending a lot of time bashing Siobhan on multiple sites. She not only bashes Siobhan but she also viciously attacks people who say good things about Siobhan. I found that this same poster also spent a lot of time bashing Sarah Palin during the 2008 election. Why would this poster spend so much time bashing these two ladies? Why would she be so obsessed with putting them down? Could it be just because she feels they have no talent? Possibly, but I doubt it. No, I think it goes far deeper than that. I am thinking she might have a problem with attractive women. Maybe some deep-seated scar that goes back to her childhood. When you see her ugly posts about Siobhan, it might be a good idea to just ignore her.

The voting last week was a disgrace. American idol is up to there tricks again just like last week. America wake up . Boycott America Idol until the last. Give Siobhan support and show her how we feel. There is no way she was on the bottom last week. Sign the petition.

oh c'mon guys! she deserves that title! get her back on the show! im really sad and shocked when i knew she was gonna leave! get her back! get her back! get her back! get her back( but wait.. is that even possible?) but i love Siobhan.. Siobhan is the best!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I will miss Siobhan very much, because she is an exciting singer and performer. In my opinion Siobhan should be reinstated by the producers of AI. They did it with Tim Urban after he was sent-off by the judges. The reason for that was never explained. If Tim Urban an average talent was given another chance, than Siobhan who is highly talented should be given another chance too.

This is really really stupid.The petition has NO basis at all.Here's a thought:Why didn't you guys just look at the TV screen after her performance??? Why in the would would you NOT watch her performance and then go on facebook to get her numbers?? Thank you for the numbers to call because I will be calling to vote against this as will thousands of others now that we have the contact info.This is NOT the fault of AI,get a life.

Sorry, but these past vote challenges go nowhere with Idol, and I'm a 50-50 believer that there were some voting problems, more a believer that Big MIke has been bottom vote getter for several weeks and is being carried as a minority. And a 100% believer that Siobhan and a few other female contestants were given the bum's rush by producers to bolster their pet contestant's chances. (the ones they think will crank out albums instantly).The thing is that AI's execs are pretty insane to make it all about the piddly revenue that they will get a cut of from AI's top 3 music sales. That is NOTHING in terms of revenue to the AI organization that comes from advertisers fees scaled to Ratings of the show itself. 98% of revenue and I expect the ratings to drop more with Siobhan not being there. And just as insane for AI to let the voting process be rabid fan little speed dialers who buy no more Ford, Coke, and music than the rest of the viewers dictate who stays on the show to the other 99% of viewers. And no, I just don't care enough or have to work the next day - to punch out several hundred text votes to "Save Didi, or save Siobhan, save Casey!"

This will only take a miracle.

I've listed the numbers and address to call and complain to Fox, 19 entertainment, and some of American Idol's sponsors on my site: http://bit.ly/cDbuot